Animal Reproduction (AR)
Animal Reproduction (AR)

In vitro and in vivo embryo production efficiency in Flemish and Holstein donor females

Fabiano Carminatti Zago; Luís Fernando Schütz; Renato Pereira da Costa Gerger; Luís Henrique de Aguiar; César Augusto Pinzón-Osorio; Alceu Mezzallira; José Luiz Rodrigues; Fabiana Forell; Marcelo Bertolini

Downloads: 0
Views: 63


Abstract: The aim of this study was to compare embryo production efficiency in Flemish and Holstein donor females using ovum pick-up and in vitro fertilization (OPU-IVF) or in vivo production (superovulation; SOV) procedures. The study was conducted using a split-plot design, with eight Flemish and eight Holstein non-lactating cycling females. Females were subjected to ten weekly OPU/IVF sessions and/or two SOV/embryo collections sessions at a 63-day interval, for a total of 160 OPU-IVF and 32 SOV sessions. Mean numbers of follicles and corpora lutea, and cumulus-oocyte complex (COC) recovery rates were similar between breeds after the OPU and SOV sessions. However, Flemish donors yielded better quality grade II COCs (301, 41.9%) than Holstein females (609, and 202, 33.1%). Also, cleavage and blastocyst rates, and the total number and the mean number of viable embryos obtained after OPU-IVF were higher in Flemish (49.6% and 11.8%, and 63 and 11.8 per donor, respectively) than in Holstein (32.8% and 7.2%, and 34 and 7.2 per donor, respectively) females. Flemish females were also more efficient in yielding viable embryos after SOV (111, 7.3 per donor) than Holstein (48, 3.3 per donor) females. Overall, Flemish donor females had better responses to OPU-IVF or SOV procedures than Holstein counterparts. Irrespective of the breeds, SOV procedures were more efficient than OPU-IVF in yielding more viable embryos, under the conditions of this study. Both reproductive procedures were useful tools for the genetic conservation of the Flemish cattle breed in Southern Brazil.


breed conservation, in vitro fertilization, multiple ovulation, ovum pick-up, cattle


Alfonzo EPM, McManus CM, Campos GS, Portes JV, Padilha AH, Peripolli V, Braccini J No. Spatial distribution of Brazilian bovine taurine breeds associated with climatic, physical and socioeconomic variables. Arq Bras Med Vet Zootec. 2021;73(3):693-702.

Aller JF, Mucci NC, Kaiser GG, Ríos G, Callejas SS, Alberio RH. Transvaginal follicular aspiration and embryo development in superstimulated early postpartum beef cows and subsequent fertility after artificial insemination. Anim Reprod Sci. 2010;119(1-2):1-8. PMid:20036087.

Aziz RLA, Khalil A, Abdel-Wahab A, Hassan NY, Abdel-Hamied E, Kasimanickam RK. Relationship among circulating anti-Müllerian hormone, insulin like growth factor 1, cadmium and superovulatory response in dairy cows. Theriogenology. 2017;100:72-9. PMid:28708536.

Baldrighi JM, Sá MF Fo, Batista EOS, Lopes RNVR, Visintin JA, Baruselli PS, Assumpção MEOA. Anti-mullerian hormone concentration and antral ovarian follicle population in Murrah heifers compared to Holstein and Gyr kept under the same management. Reprod Domest Anim. 2014;49(6):1015-20. PMid:25291989.

Batista EO, Guerreiro BM, Freitas BG, Silva JC, Vieira LM, Ferreira RM, Rezende RG, Basso AC, Lopes RN, Rennó FP, Souza AH, Baruselli PS. Plasma anti-Müllerian hormone as a predictive endocrine marker to select Bos taurus (Holstein) and Bos indicus (Nelore) calves for in vitro embryo production. Domest Anim Endocrinol. 2016;54:1-9. PMid:26379099.

Bó GA, Baruselli PS, Chesta PM, Martins CM. The timing of ovulation and insemination schedules in superstimulated cattle. Theriogenology. 2006;65(1):89-101. PMid:16293299.

Bó GA, Mapletoft RJ. Superstimulation of ovarian follicles in cattle: gonadotropin treatment protocols and FSH profiles. Theriogenology. 2020;150:353-9. PMid:32088042.

Clasen JB, Kargo M, Fikse WF, Strandberg E, Wallenbeck A, Østergaard S, Rydhmer L. Conservation of a native dairy cattle breed through terminal crossbreeding with commercial dairy breeds. Acta Agric Scand A Anim Sci. 2021;70(1):1-12.

Cruz FB, Oliveira I Jr, Vieira AD, Gerger RPC, Ribeiro ES, Bertolini M, Mezzalira A. Recoleta uterina como estratégia para aumentar a taxa de embriões em fêmeas bovinas de corte e leite. Acta Sci Vet. 2008;36(3):249-54.

Dalton JC, Nadir S, Bame JH, Noftsinger M, Saacke RG. The effect of time of artificial insemination on fertilization status and embryo quality in superovulated cows. J Anim Sci. 2000;78(8):2081-5. PMid:10947091.

De Roover R, Feugang JMN, Bols PEJ, Genicot G, Hanzen C. Effects of ovum pick-up frequency and fsh stimulation: a retrospective study on seven years of beef cattle in vitro embryo production. Reprod Domest Anim. 2008;43(2):239-45. PMid:18226024.

Facioli FL, De Marchi F, Marques MG, Michelon PRP, Zanella EL, Caires KC, Reeves JJ, Zanella R. The outcome and economic viability of embryo production using IVF and SOV techniques in the wagyu breed of cattle. Vet Sci. 2020;7(2):58. PMid:32369966.

Feres LF, Siqueira LGB, Palhao MP, Santos LL, Brandao FZ, Viana JHM. Likelihood of pregnancy after the transfer of embryos derived from follicle aspiration and in vitro embryo production sessions with different relative efficiencies. Anim Reprod Sci. 2018;193:165-70. PMid:29678568.

Gicquel E, Boettcher P, Besbes B, Furre S, Fernández J, Danchin-Burge C, Berger B, Baumung R, Feijóo J, Leroy G. Impact of conservation measures on demography and genetic variability of livestock breeds. Animal. 2020;14(4):670-80. PMid:31685075.

Godde CM, Mason-D’Croz D, Mayberry DE, Thornton PK, Herrero M. Impacts of climate change on the livestock food supply chain; a review of the evidence. Glob Food Sec. 2021;28:100488. PMid:33738188.

Goetten ALF, Mezzalira A, Zago FC, Portela VM. Characterization of the follicular dynamic patterns in a red flemish herd in Southern Brazil. Acta Sci Vet. 2015;43:1-6.

González A, Wang H, Carruthers T, Murphy B, Mapletoft R. Increased ovulation rates in PMSG-stimulated beef heifers treated with a monoclonal PMSG antibody. Theriogenology. 1994;41(8):1631-42.

Gross JJ. Dairy cow physiology and production limits. Anim Front. 2023;13(3):44-50. PMid:37490567.

Guerreiro BM, Batista EO, Vieira LM, Sá MF Fo, Rodrigues CA, Castro A No, Silveira CR, Bayeux BM, Dias EA, Monteiro FM, Accorsi M, Lopes RN, Baruselli PS. Plasma anti-mullerian hormone: an endocrine marker for in vitro embryo production from Bos taurus and Bos indicus donors. Domest Anim Endocrinol. 2014;49:96-104. PMid:25136816.

Guimarães ASB, Rocha LF, Jesus RDL, Vasconcelos GL, Anghinoni G, Santana ALA, Barbosa LP. In vitro performance of Zebu (Bos indicus) and Taurus (Bos taurus) donor cow embryos. Rev Bras Saúde Prod Anim. 2020;21:e21200142020.

Hansen PJ. The incompletely fulfilled promise of embryo transfer in cattle-why aren’t pregnancy rates greater and what can we do about it? J Anim Sci. 2020;98(11):skaa288. PMid:33141879.

Holm P, Booth PJ, Schmidt MH, Greve T, Callesen H. High bovine blastocyst development in a static in vitro production system using SOFaa medium supplemented with sodium citrate and myo-inositol with or without serum-proteins. Theriogenology. 1999;52(4):683-700. PMid:10734366.

Karadjole M, Getz I, Samardžija M, Maćešić N, Matkovi M, Makek Z, Karadjole T, Bačić G, Dobrani T, Poletto M. The developmental competence of bovine immature oocytes and he developmental competence of bovine immature oocytes and quality of embryos derived from slaughterhouse ovaries or live uality of embryos derived from slaughterhouse ovaries or live donors by ovum pick up onors by ovum pick up. Vet Arh. 2010;80:445-54.

Lafontaine S, Labrecque R, Blondin P, Cue RI, Sirard MA. Comparison of cattle derived from in vitro fertilization, multiple ovulation embryo transfer, and artificial insemination for milk production and fertility traits. J Dairy Sci. 2023;106(6):4380-96. PMid:37028966.

Lauvie A, Danchin-Burge C, Audiot A, Brives H, Casabianca F, Verrier E. A controversy about crossbreeding in a conservation programme: the case study of the Flemish Red cattle breed. Livest Sci. 2008;118(1-2):113-22.

Liu X, Li Z, Yan Y, Li Y, Wu H, Pei J, Yan P, Yang R, Guo X, Lan X. Selection and introgression facilitated the adaptation of Chinese native endangered cattle in extreme environments. Evol Appl. 2021;14(3):860-73. PMid:33767758.

Lopes AS, Martinussen T, Greve T, Callesen H. Effect of days post-partum, breed and ovum pick-up scheme on bovine oocyte recovery and embryo development. Reprod Domest Anim. 2006;41(3):196-203. PMid:16689881.

Lopes da Costa L, Chagas e Silva J, Silva Robalo J. Superovulatory response, embryo quality and fertility after treatment with different gonadotrophins in native cattle. Theriogenology. 2001;56(1):65-77. PMid:11467519.

Machado GM, Carvalho JO, Siqueira E Fo, Caixeta ES, Franco MM, Rumpf R, Dode MAN. Effect of Percoll volume, duration and force of centrifugation, on in vitro production and sex ratio of bovine embryos. Theriogenology. 2009;71(8):1289-97. PMid:19230963.

Manik RS, Singla SK, Palta P. Collection of oocytes through transvaginal ultrasound-guided aspiration of follicles in an Indian breed of cattle. Anim Reprod Sci. 2003;76(3-4):155-61. PMid:12586489.

Marian L, Withoeft JA, Costa LDS, Ribeiro LR, Melo IC, Alves RS, Baumbach LF, Pinto MGL, Snak A, Miletti LC, Ferraz SM, Sfaciotte RAP, Canal CW, Casagrande RA. Causes of fetal death in the Flemish cattle herd in Brazil. Vet World. 2023;16(4):766-72. PMid:37235167.

Mastromonaco GF, Gonzalez-Grajales AL. Reproduction in female wild cattle: influence of seasonality on ARTs. Theriogenology. 2020;150:396-404. PMid:32081408.

Mikkola M, Taponen J. Embryo yield in dairy cattle after superovulation with Folltropin or Pluset. Theriogenology. 2017;88:84-8. PMid:27865416.

Monteiro FM, Batista E, Vieira LM, Bayeux BM, Accorsi M, Campanholi SP, Dias E, Souza AH, Baruselli PS. Beef donor cows with high number of retrieved COC produce more in vitro embryos compared with cows with low number of COC after repeated ovum pick-up sessions. Theriogenology. 2017;90:54-8. PMid:28166988.

Naranjo Chacón F, Montiel Palacios F, Canseco Sedano R, Ahuja-Aguirre C. Embryo production after superovulation of bovine donors with a reduced number of FSH applications and an increased eCG dose. Theriogenology. 2020;141:168-72. PMid:31542520.

Naranjo-Chacón F, Montiel-Palacios F, Canseco-Sedano R, Ahuja-Aguirre C. Embryo production in middle-aged and mature Bos taurus × Bos indicus cows induced to multiple ovulation in a tropical environment. Trop Anim Health Prod. 2019;51(8):2641-4. PMid:31222711.

Oliveira ATD, Lopes RFF, Rodrigues JL. Gene expression and developmental competence of bovine embryos produced in vitro with different serum concentrations. Reprod Domest Anim. 2006;41(2):129-36. PMid:16519718.

Oliveira SC, Serapião RV, Camargo AJR, Freitas C, Iguma LT, Carvalho BC, Camargo LSA, Oliveira LZ, Verneque RS. Oocyte origin affects the in vitro embryo production and development of Holstein (Bos taurus taurus) - Gyr (Bos taurus indicus) reciprocal cross embryos. Anim Reprod Sci. 2019;209:106165. PMid:31514926.

Parra GAC, Taramuel LGC, Bustos JJG. Evaluation of the productive characteristics of the Caqueteño Creole cattle breed. Trop Anim Health Prod. 2020;52(6):3241-50. PMid:32783132.

Parrish JJ, Susko-Parrish J, Winer MA, First NL. Capacitation of bovine sperm by heparin. Biol Reprod. 1988;38(5):1171-80. PMid:3408784.

Pieterse MC, Kappen KA, Kruip TAM, Taverne MAM. Aspiration of bovine oocytes during transvaginal ultrasound scanning of the ovaries. Theriogenology. 1988;30(4):751-62. PMid:16726517.

Pontes JH, Nonato-Junior I, Sanches BV, Ereno-Junior JC, Uvo S, Barreiros TR, Oliveira JA, Hasler JF, Seneda MM. Comparison of embryo yield and pregnancy rate between in vivo and in vitro methods in the same Nelore (Bos indicus) donor cows. Theriogenology. 2009;71(4):690-7. PMid:18995895.

Pontes JH, Silva KC, Basso AC, Rigo AG, Ferreira CR, Santos GM, Sanches BV, Porcionato JP, Vieira PH, Faifer FS, Sterza FA, Schenk JL, Seneda MM. Large-scale in vitro embryo production and pregnancy rates from Bos taurus, Bos indicus, and indicus-taurus dairy cows using sexed sperm. Theriogenology. 2010;74(8):1349-55. PMid:20708245.

Ribeiro ES, Gerger RPC, Ohlweiler LU, Ortigari I Jr, Mezzalira JC, Forell F, Bertolini LR, Rodrigues JL, Ambrósio CE, Miglino MA, Mezzalira A, Bertolini M. Developmental potential of bovine hand-made clone embryos reconstructed by aggregation or fusion with distinct cytoplasmic volumes. Cloning Stem Cells. 2009;11(3):377-86. PMid:19751109.

Rizos D, Burke L, Duffy P, Wade M, Mee JF, O’Farrell KJ, MacSiurtain M, Boland MP, Lonergan P. Comparisons between nulliparous heifers and cows as oocyte donors for embryo production in vitro. Theriogenology. 2005;63(3):939-49. PMid:15629810.

Sartori R, Sartor-Bergfelt R, Mertens SA, Guenther JN, Parrish JJ, Wiltbank MC. Fertilization and early embryonic development in heifers and lactating cows in summer and lactating and dry cows in winter. J Dairy Sci. 2002;85(11):2803-12. PMid:12487447.

Seneda MM, Esper CR, Garcia JM, Andrade ER, Binelli M, Oliveira JA, Nascimento AB. Efficacy of linear and convex transducers for ultrasound-guided transvaginal follicle aspiration. Theriogenology. 2003;59(5-6):1435-40. PMid:12527089.

Seneda MM, Esper CR, Garcia JM, Oliveira JA, Vantini R. Relationship between follicle size and ultrasound-guided transvaginal oocyte recovery. Anim Reprod Sci. 2001;67(1-2):37-43. PMid:11408112.

Silva-Santos KC, Santos GM, Siloto LS, Hertel MF, Andrade ER, Rubin MI, Sturion L, Melo-Sterza FA, Seneda MM. Estimate of the population of preantral follicles in the ovaries of Bos taurus indicus and Bos taurus taurus cattle. Theriogenology. 2011;76(6):1051-7. PMid:21722949.

Souza AH, Carvalho PD, Rozner AE, Vieira LM, Hackbart KS, Bender RW, Dresch AR, Verstegen JP, Shaver RD, Wiltbank MC. Relationship between circulating anti-Müllerian hormone (AMH) and superovulatory response of high-producing dairy cows. J Dairy Sci. 2015;98(1):169-78. PMid:25465542.

Steinhauser CB, Looney CR, Hasler JF, Renaud P. Retrospective analysis of superstimulation with Folltropin®-V in Wagyu versus other beef breeds. Anim Reprod. 2018;15:553.

Stojkovic M, Machado SA, Stojkovic P, Zakhartchenko V, Hutzler P, Goncalves PB, Wolf E. Mitochondrial distribution and adenosine triphosphate content of bovine oocytes before and after in vitro maturation: correlation with morphological criteria and developmental capacity after in vitro fertilization and culture. Biol Reprod. 2001;64(3):904-9. PMid:11207207.

Stringfellow DA, Givens MD. Manual of the International Embryo Transfer Society: a procedural guide and general information for the use of embryo transfer technology emphasizing sanitary procedures. 4th ed. Savoy: IETS Publish; 2009.

Sunds AV, Bunyatratchata A, Robinson R, Glantz M, Paulsson M, Leskauskaite D, Pihlanto A, Inglingstad R, Devold TG, Vegarud GE, Birgisdottir BE, Gudjonsdottir M, Barile D, Larsen LB, Poulsen NA. Comparison of bovine milk oligosaccharides in native North European cattle breeds. Int Dairy J. 2021;114:104917. PMid:33304057.

Taberlet P, Valentini A, Rezaei HR, Naderi S, Pompanon F, Negrini R, Ajmone-Marsan P. Are cattle, sheep, and goats endangered species? Mol Ecol. 2008;17(1):275-84. PMid:17927711.

Tamassia M, Heyman Y, Lavergne Y, Richard C, Gelin V, Renard JP, Chastant-Maillard S. Evidence of oocyte donor cow effect over oocyte production and embryo development in vitro. Reproduction. 2003;126(5):629-37. PMid:14611636.

Tanaka Y, Nakada K, Moriyoshi M, Sawamukai Y. Appearance and number of follicles and change in the concentration of serum FSH in female bovine fetuses. Reproduction. 2001;121(5):777-82. PMid:11427166.

Thaler A No, Mühibauer MD, Ramos JC, Zardo WF. Fatores que afetam a produção de leite e o período de lactação em um rebanho das raças Flamenga e Holandesa no Planalto Catarinense. Cienc Rural. 1996;26(1):123-8.

Torres-Simental JF, Peña-Calderón C, Avendaño-Reyes L, Correa-Calderón A, Macías-Cruz U, Rodríguez-Borbón A, Leyva-Corona JC, Rivera-Acuña F, Thomas MG, Luna-Nevárez P. Predictive markers for superovulation response and embryo production in beef cattle managed in northwest Mexico are influenced by climate. Livest Sci. 2021;250:104590.

Vajta G, Holm P, Greve T, Callesen H. The submarine incubation system, a new tool for in vitro embryo culture: a technique report. Theriogenology. 1997;48(8):1379-85.

Vasconcelos GL, Cunha EV, Maculan R, Sánchez Viafara JA, Silva AWB, Batista ALS, Silva JRV, Souza JC. Effects of vulvar width and antral follicle count on oocyte quality, in vitro embryo production and pregnancy rate in Bos taurus taurus and Bos taurus indicus cows. Anim Reprod Sci. 2020;217:106357. PMid:32408964.

Yadav MC, Walton JS, Leslie KE. Timing of the onset and duration of ovulation in superovulated beef heifers. Theriogenology. 1986;26(4):509-21. PMid:16726216.

Zander KK, Signorello G, Salvo M, Gandini G, Drucker AG. Assessing the total economic value of threatened livestock breeds in Italy: implications for conservation policy. Ecol Econ. 2013;93:219-29.

Submitted date:

Accepted date:

653826a0a9539531232c8903 animreprod Articles
Links & Downloads

Anim Reprod

Share this page
Page Sections